melange
Dashing Rogue
Posts: 36
Likes: 185
|
Post by melange on Oct 15, 2019 17:56:45 GMT
First off, sorry to re-appear just to post negative drama or rain on anyone's parade. But I've been chatting about this game over on Twitter with Nick, and he suggested I pop back in to share some screencaps. Tldr: If you're looking forward to this game for the f/f romance potential, I'd be careful. Gaider's out on Twitter today, posting about how he's ~begrudgingly~ reading lesbian fanfic for research for this game, and making it sound like it's something he'd rather not do. Really great. Disclaimer: I'm pretty neutral on Gaider, so this isn't anything against him personally. But the way he's like UGH about having to read this stuff, and dodging everyone's advice to consult actual lesbians, really makes me kinda :/ The company can hire famous voice actors, but not a single lesbian that can give input on the writing? Idk. Disappointing to see.
|
|
|
Post by farferello on Oct 15, 2019 18:06:08 GMT
Wow... that's... wow. Though coming from Gaider I shouldn't be surprised but yeah, if my interest in this game wasn't already gone, I think this would have put me right off. The fact he seems so intent on 'torturing' himself this way rather than hiring a lesbian writer, or hell, even asking lesbians/bi women for advice rather than fanfic prompts is worrying. If anyone's still interested in this game, expect the f/m to be far superior whilst the f/f is... likely going to be worse or problematic.
The thing about Gaider is that no matter how much you try and tell him the f/f content will suffer without female input, he's too stubborn to address the situation with anything but brute force. People have tried to talk to him in the past about things and he has only ever come across as a rude sulky man-baby.
|
|
|
Post by Davrin's boobs on Oct 15, 2019 18:10:04 GMT
Thanks Melange for posting those screencaps! As many of you know Gaider blocked me because of this so I didnt know he was posting that kind of tweets til Melange brought me the news lol I really hope he can do good for F/F romances and WLW players but I think it is worth posting those tweets to warn people just in case. I know there are some hardcore fans of his writing here (I'm kinda one of them if I count his straight romances lol) but as someone that it's very wary of his writing I think it is safe to warn people here to be wary too, relying on fanfiction (often written by straight men) is kinda icky. Anyone would think that writing straight romances is weirder than writing lesbian romances coming from a gay man but here we are lol apparently is too much for him. I hope they hire or consult lesbian/bi women for this... Best of luck and I hope f/f romances are super cool! edit. although I'm salty how this pretty much confirm again how straight people are the focus even when two gay men are in charge, Apollo is a confirmed f/m option but Gaider didn't even start writing f/f options it's so fucking sad lol
|
|
melange
Dashing Rogue
Posts: 36
Likes: 185
|
Post by melange on Oct 15, 2019 18:16:09 GMT
Yeah, I'm definitely not telling anyone to boycott the game or anything like that! Just be careful and get excited with a grain of salt, because I don't want people to get hyped up and then disappointed if this is how the main writer is approaching writing wlw. I'm someone that was pretty let down over the fixed protagonist, but I was eventually going to play it anyway and angle for the f/f romance, so this is just all around kinda :/ sighhh.
|
|
Catilina
The Beastmaster
Wanted Apostate
Posts: 827
Likes: 3,282
|
Post by Catilina on Oct 19, 2019 13:34:34 GMT
Okay, now I don't really interested sadly, (yet?), also the musical isn't my thing – while clearly original idea... This is the early phase, I hope, we'll see the improvement.
|
|
|
Post by gimolas on Oct 19, 2019 18:14:22 GMT
lol Yikes at those tweets. Lesbians aren't some mythical creature, their relationships aren't any more mysterious than f/m or m/m ones. Like, just write them like they are people and then have a lady writer proofread it to make sure there's no /r/menwritingwomen weirdness going on.
|
|
|
Post by Davrin's boobs on Oct 19, 2019 18:44:57 GMT
aren't some mythical creature you're implying that lgbtq people are not magical and have no supernatural powers? also tweets of this studio keep popping in my timeline even though I unfollowed them so i keep being annoying asking for WLW options, dont worry I love being a pain in the ass on twitter is something vocational to me
|
|
|
Post by gimolas on Oct 20, 2019 0:35:36 GMT
I love being a pain in the ass on twitter is something vocational to me You're a twitter wizard, you're like always fighting people on there or somehow getting game devs to talk to you and I don't know how you do it. lol
|
|
|
Post by Lee on Oct 20, 2019 2:24:20 GMT
I've already felt attacked for talking about DG before. I'll just say this and move on...Not today Satan.
|
|
|
Post by dgcatanisiri on Oct 21, 2019 13:12:27 GMT
The thing is... Applying logic to Gaider is a fool's errand, I know, but if you're SO... I'll be charitable and say uncomfortable with writing for F/F relationships, why NOT hand them off to someone else? Someone who can do them justice that you clearly don't seem willing or able to do?
Honestly, between this and the rather dismissive way he handled people trying to say "the depiction of Sera triggered me/was exactly like my abusive ex," I'm really inclined to say that Gaider is one of those gay men whose disinterest in women slides into casual misogyny.
Like... I'm sorry, why, specifically, are you looking at lesbian fanfic PORN for this? Like, the impression I get of this game is that it's in a similar vein as Coming Out On Top or Dream Daddy, and while the first was sexually explicit and came with actual sex scenes, the later was definitely prone to tasteful cuts to black and explicit build but not actual explicit sex. Shouldn't you just be looking for lesbian ROMANCE? Even before getting to the gross way that lesbian porn is frequently just made for straight guys (admittedly not as big a thing in the realm of fanfic, but still...)
|
|
|
Post by Davrin's boobs on Nov 2, 2019 12:33:11 GMT
|
|
|
Post by mediocreogre on Nov 2, 2019 19:35:48 GMT
The thing is... Applying logic to Gaider is a fool's errand, I know, but if you're SO... I'll be charitable and say uncomfortable with writing for F/F relationships, why NOT hand them off to someone else? Someone who can do them justice that you clearly don't seem willing or able to do? Honestly, between this and the rather dismissive way he handled people trying to say "the depiction of Sera triggered me/was exactly like my abusive ex," I'm really inclined to say that Gaider is one of those gay men whose disinterest in women slides into casual misogyny. Like... I'm sorry, why, specifically, are you looking at lesbian fanfic PORN for this? Like, the impression I get of this game is that it's in a similar vein as Coming Out On Top or Dream Daddy, and while the first was sexually explicit and came with actual sex scenes, the later was definitely prone to tasteful cuts to black and explicit build but not actual explicit sex. Shouldn't you just be looking for lesbian ROMANCE? Even before getting to the gross way that lesbian porn is frequently just made for straight guys (admittedly not as big a thing in the realm of fanfic, but still...) Yep. My thoughts exactly. Gaider is a mess. One of those people you have to respect for doing the bare minimum when 99% of people were doing less than nothing but now it feels like it is time for the braver, more passionate, and less bitter people to have more creative control. (Also maybe some day we should all have a chat about how his magnum opus, DA, has a ton of abuse (also sexual abuse) of women in it). i agree with everyone saying be cautious with this one.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 4, 2019 15:35:45 GMT
Cool fanart! Olivia Rea ☁️ @nephelolivia CHORUS fanart 🎵🎶 I adore RPGs, mythology, and Wintory's compositions, so I am Very Excited for this game!! #chorusgame #digitalart #fanart #artistsontwitter Summerfall Studios @summerfallgames We just hit 90%, and as a thank you, here's an awesome new wallpaper by @theboyofcheese! Keep it up, hopefully we can hit some of our stretch goals and get some extra romances and maybe even some extra songs! ✨
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 8, 2019 17:34:49 GMT
Looks like extra romances stretchgoal has been reached.
Summerfall Studios @summerfallgames First Stretch Goal cleared! ✨ Who’s ready to romance Pan and/or Freddie? ❤️
|
|